Part two in a series on Cloud CRM vs. On-premises
Semi-Hosted CRM for Greater Speed While Connecting Remote Locations
Another common scenario in the cloud CRM versus on-premises debate (or hosted Vs non-hosted CRM) is illustrated via one client we have where they know that their IT guys don’t have the skills to execute CRM as technology platform and as a strategy but they have the capacity to provide some servers.
So we are being engaged to be their primary hosting service where all the “smarts”, all the management, all the infrastructure and being the central hub for sharing all the data throughout the organisation is done by us – but it is semi-hosted. They have offices in Melbourne and Sydney. We’re putting a local server in their buildings so they can have access to their data at landspeed, but that server sends its changes back to us and we send it to Sydney. Meanwhile the Sydney users get their data access and the stuff that actually moves between them happens at a relaxed rate.
So it’s not purely cloud CRM and it’s not purely on-premises but a hybrid model. They’re getting this service internally so it’s fast but the management of it is done by us offsite because they just need it done. They might have a short deployment, it might be a conflict in resources, it might be that they just don’t have the people, but whatever the reason, they need it and that’s where we come in.
So we do the heavy lifting in terms of management and deployment offsite but the customer still provides local cached services so that the users experience great performance.
2 Reasons Companies Choose On-Premises CRM
And the last scenario is “Actually I don’t want it hosted at all, I want it on premise”.
Generally that falls in to two categories:
You can’t really do that that well in a hosted environment because otherwise all of the data interchange is going over the Internet and I am not really sure that many customers are going to be all that delighted about their financials flying all over the ether.
Even though you can put security connections around it all, it is still risky. In a hosted accounting system, and goodness knows there are an increasing amount of them, the data is in a hosted environment but the actual data itself is not being transmitted – it’s screens and keywords so it’s actually secure for a different reason in as much as we’re not transmitting the data over the Internet whereas integration over the Internet is a little bit more complicated. Security-wise, it’s just not there yet.
CRM Strategy Vs CRM Stopgap
So at the end of the day the conversation over hosted or non-hosted comes down to a couple of things. If all you want to do is just have a throwaway, “I just need something for now” solution then there are plenty of services out there but you shouldn’t really expect anything by way of return on investment by anything other than wild surprise.
The rest of them are “I’m executing a strategy, but I am picking the best way to use it”.
So it comes down to your capacity to support CRM as running cost, or as a skills and expertise issue, or a timing issue – whatever – but that shouldn’t detract from what the solution looks like. One thing that we have observed and constantly tested is that browser applications tend to be very, very disposable.
This is Part 2 in a 4 part series. Read the next entry. Read the First entry
Brett Cruickshank, MIMC
Managing Director, CRM Strategy
Mobile: 0419 631 375
Email: brettc@crmstrategy.com.au
I believe that the hosted CRM vs. non-hosted (or cloud CRM vs. on-premises) argument is a red herring that needs to be reframed as CRM Strategy vs. Stopgap.
If it’s the latter then hosted or non-hosted, cloud or on-premise CRM – it doesn’t even come into play. It’s a non-issue.
If it’s the former and you’re just buying it without a strategy then you’re probably doing more damage than good. You’ve deemed that lack of access to customer data is not a threat – but relationships (and selling IS relationships), customer data and what you know about the customer IS the game.
Why CRM Minus Strategy Doesn’t Work
There are a couple of schools of thought when it comes to hosted (cloud) CRM. One of the schools of thought is: “I don’t really know what I need but I know I need something. I either don’t have the time, don’t have the energy or I don’t really know how to describe what I really want but I want something because everybody is screaming at me.”
“But I’m not really ready to go through an in-depth needs analysis, so I’ll get some online thing.”
They ask themselves “What do I know about? Actually I know about Salesforce. I’ve seen that around, that’s probably going to be OK”. So provided it doesn’t kill them financially, they buy 5, 10, 15 users and boom: “There’s your CRM. There’s a place you can put your data. Now go away and stop bothering me”.
It’s not strategy, but they’ve got something so they can say “I’ve delivered CRM”. And they can start to use it. What generally happens then is you’ll get some data into it, you’ll get a couple of evangelists who’ll go off and do something with it and you’ll get a couple of other people who will do the mandatory minimum or nothing at all.
It’s probably about a 15 – 20% chance of it igniting and only if one of the evangelists happens to have the ear of anybody senior.
But successful adoption tends to be flukey. So there’s no necessary guarantee of outcome. But what it does enable them to do is to use their credit card to solve a problem. It doesn’t involve IT so they can go around a lot of work and just say “There’s a subscription, knock yourself out”. It doesn’t appear as a capital cost so they didn’t have to budget for it. They can just put it into an operating budget and deal with it easily.
This scenario is not the ideal way because it doesn’t really get you anywhere. It just puts a finger in the dam and stops it from dripping until you get back to it.
This is Part 1 in a 4 part series. Read the next entry.
Brett Cruickshank, MIMC
Managing Director, CRM Strategy
Mobile: 0419 631 375
Email: brettc@crmstrategy.com.au
A case study of how Panasonic enjoy the benefits of Sage SalesLogix CRM